Again in April 2020, the landlocked West Texas Intermediate crude oil worth briefly crashed into unfavorable territory – a shocking flip of occasions that price merchants large losses – when the spot oil market discovered itself with an unprecedented glut as there was actually an excessive amount of oil to be saved, and as such these merchants who had been assigned supply would pay others simply to take the bodily oil off their arms. Effectively, in only a few weeks we may even see the alternative state of affairs: no bodily oil in any respect within the largest US industrial storage facility, resulting in what could also be a superspike within the worth of oil.
In a be aware predicting the near-term dynamics of the oil market, JPMorgan’s commodity Natasha Kaneva writes that in a world of pervasive nat fuel and coal shortages that are forcing the ability sector to more and more flip to grease (boosting demand by 750bkd throughout winter and drawing stock by 2.1mmb/d in Nov and Dec), Cushing oil storage – which simply dropped to 31.2mm barrels, the bottom since 2018…
… could also be simply weeks from being “successfully out of crude.” The financial institution’s conclusion: “if nothing had been to vary within the Cushing stability over the subsequent two months, we would count on entrance WTI spreads to spike to document highs—a “tremendous backwardation” state of affairs.”
Earlier than we get into the meat of the be aware, first some background which as normal nowadays, begins with Europe’s catastrophic dealing with of its power wants.
As JPM notes, the heating season of 2021/2022 is opening with document excessive international fuel costs whilst chilly winter climate has but to reach. Such are the quirks of the pure fuel market that, when/if chilly winter arrives, demand for fuel tends to outpace any supply of provide. Within the US alone, in a given week in winter, pure fuel demand can surge by 50-70 bcf, if no more, with restricted response from provide. The scenario is so dire in the mean time that – JPMorgan observes – “discovering even 1 bcf of spare capability is changing into more and more troublesome.”
Associated: The 2021 Oil Value Rally Is Far From Over
The excellent news is that with Russian home fuel storage websites 97% full, stockpiling must be finalized by November 1, probably releasing 4-10 bcm of extra shipments to Europe. Nevertheless, on Monday we reported that Gazprom had booked solely 35% of Yamal-Europe exit pipeline capability for November (similar as in October) and selected to not guide extra transit volumes by way of Ukraine, implying that Russia shouldn’t be at the moment planning to ship extra fuel to Europe at the least till Nord Stream 2 is absolutely licensed.
And as JPM notes, echoing what Goldman stated earlier this week, “with out extra Russian volumes, the winter climate premium at the moment embedded within the European pure fuel worth can not considerably diminish till outlook for January climate turns into extra sure.”
Briefly, even greater nat fuel costs are on deck, particularly if the winter is chilly.
So with document coal and fuel costs, the ability sector and power intensive industries are turning to grease, probably boosting demand by 750 kbd throughout winter and drawing oil stock by 2.1 mbd over November and December. Earlier as we speak, Reuters quoted Saudi Arabia’s Minister of Vitality Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman who confirmed that customers switching from fuel to grease might account for demand of 500,000-600,000 barrels per day (bpd), including that the world was now waking as much as shortages within the power sector.
Abdulaziz stated the potential swap relied on how extreme winter climate could be and the way costly different power costs could be. He outlined a variety of things which have led to a current spike in power costs, together with restricted funding in hydrocarbons and infrastructure, low inventories, the lifting of pandemic lockdowns and COVID-19 vaccine uptake charges.
Associated: Oil Rebounds On Shock Crude Stock Draw
“Individuals unexpectedly woke as much as the truth that they’re operating out of all the things: they’re ran out of investments, they ran out of shares they usually ran out of … creativity in making an attempt to be attending to actual answer that deal with actual points,” Prince Abdulaziz advised the CERA Week India Vitality Discussion board.
In any case, within the clearest instance but of market tightness, Cushing crude storage fell to 31.2 mb final week as famous within the chart above. And since operational tank bottoms are doubtless 20-25% of capacity- or about 20 mb – JPM predicts that “we could possibly be simply weeks away from Cushing being successfully out of crude” and provides that “if nothing had been to vary within the Cushing stability over the subsequent two months, we would count on entrance WTI spreads to spike to document highs—a “tremendous backwardation” state of affairs.“
If JPM’s prediction is right – and recall simply yesterday we printed an analogous take from Morgan Stanley which now expects an analogous “peak provide” state of affairs taking part in out, if over the long term prompting the financial institution to hike its Q1 2022 worth goal to $95 from $77.5/bbl – it will have a catastrophic (learn greater) influence on the worth of oil.
After all, there are potential mitigating components: as Kaneva notes, although the dynamics of the US crude stability are completely different than they had been in 2018 and far completely different than they had been in 2014—the final two occasions Cushing drew down towards operational limits—the market nonetheless has just a few levers to drag earlier than we fear about such a state of affairs.
Right this moment, the oil market is already reacting to the likelihood that Cushing inventories backside out and the export arb from the US Gulf Coast to Northwest Europe has been closed since 14 Oct. Consequently, the financial institution expects US crude exports to fall to an common 2.0-2.2 mbd by mid-November, with most of that ~500 kbd lower coming from flows to Europe.
However whereas this can be excellent news for the US, it is much more unhealthy information for Europe – this discount in flows to Europe would come at a time when European crude markets are already fairly tight. In response to information from Kpler, Europe crude oil shares are already at their lowest since late 2018. Since 15 July, Europe crude shares have fallen 35 mb, a charge of 362 kbd.
European exports apart, and specializing in Cushing inbound flows, JPM notes that final week the Steele Metropolis to Cushing part of the Keystone pipeline halted for 3 days as Keystone shifted flows to Patoka and the pipeline was nonetheless flowing at a a lot decrease than regular charge early this week, although flows seem like again above 400 kbd this morning.
Complete Keystone flows fell on Tuesday as flows to Patoka slowed as nicely. If Keystone flows to Cushing—usually 350-625 kbd—return constantly to regular quickly, Cushing could be a lot nearer to stability. Nevertheless, if the shift in flows is meant to function line fill for Capline, Keystone will not be a short-term answer to the Cushing tank bottoms situation.
Capline ought to require about 5.2 mb of line fill in whole. With start-up not deliberate till 1 Jan, the speed of line fill shouldn’t be greater than about 100 kbd. Whereas this extra tightness within the PADD 2 crude stability actually doesn’t assist issues at Cushing, it must be greater than offset by the continued ramp up of the 760 kbd Line 3 Alternative, JPM suggests.
Lastly, flows on the Enbridge Mainline group of pipelines, which incorporates the Line 3 Alternative, have solely elevated about 200 kbd for the reason that begin of Line 3, which suggests the potential for far more crude quantity flowing into PADD 2 could possibly be simply throughout the horizon, assuming Canadian producers are keen and capable of provide them.
Extra Prime Reads From Oilprice.com: